This phrase signifies a need for narratives much like Donna Tartt’s famend novel. Readers in search of comparable experiences usually search for parts comparable to a give attention to close-knit teams of pals, a darkish or atmospheric setting, morally ambiguous characters, explorations of classical literature or philosophy, and a plot pushed by secrets and techniques and transgressions. For instance, a reader may be drawn to the intricate relationships and remoted ambiance, the affect of historic Greek research on the characters’ lives, or the gradual burn of suspense resulting in a dramatic climax.
Exploring fiction with these shared traits offers readers with alternatives to delve into complicated psychological themes, expertise immersive storytelling, and have interaction with intellectually stimulating content material. The enduring reputation of narratives that includes these parts highlights a sustained curiosity in exploring the human situation inside rarefied or intense social dynamics. Such narratives can provide readers highly effective insights into the results of decisions, the character of friendship and betrayal, and the enduring energy of secrets and techniques. Their exploration contributes considerably to ongoing discussions of morality, identification, and the human expertise inside the context of literature.
The next sections will delve into particular authors and titles that resonate with the qualities readers admire in Tartt’s work. These suggestions will present a wealthy choice for these in search of comparable literary experiences, categorized by theme, model, and ambiance to facilitate discovery.
1. Shut-knit Teams
The dynamics of close-knit teams type an important component in narratives harking back to The Secret Historical past. These teams usually operate as microcosms of society, intensifying feelings, fostering each deep loyalty and simmering rivalries. The inherent insularity of such teams creates an surroundings ripe for secrets and techniques and transgressions, as particular person actions reverberate powerfully inside the confined social area. The stress to evolve to group norms, coupled with the concern of ostracization, can lead characters down morally ambiguous paths. Take into account the Bloomsbury Group, a real-world instance of a close-knit mental circle whose members, regardless of their artistic brilliance, skilled complicated interpersonal relationships and dramatic conflicts fueled by their shut proximity and shared ambitions.
The exclusivity of those teams contributes considerably to the narrative rigidity. Characters inside the circle usually develop a way of superiority, believing themselves to be separate from and maybe above standard societal guidelines. This fosters an surroundings the place transgressions can escalate, fueled by a way of shared duty and the assumption that the group’s bonds will defend them from exterior penalties. Moreover, the extreme emotional connections inside the group may be exploited, as characters leverage their understanding of one another’s vulnerabilities and needs to govern the narrative’s course. This will result in betrayals that carry profound weight, shattering the group’s fastidiously constructed phantasm of unity.
Understanding the dynamics of close-knit teams offers essential perception into the motivations and actions of characters in these narratives. It underscores the facility of belonging, the attract of exclusivity, and the potential for each extraordinary creativity and harmful battle. The examination of those dynamics gives beneficial perspective on the complexities of human relationships and the results of working inside a closed social system. This evaluation additional enriches the studying expertise, offering a framework for understanding the underlying tensions that drive the narrative ahead.
2. Darkish Academia
Darkish academia serves as a big thematic and aesthetic component in narratives much like The Secret Historical past. This subgenre, characterised by its romanticized depiction of mental pursuits and elite instructional settings, usually explores themes of ambition, obsession, and the attract of forbidden information. The setting itself, sometimes a prestigious college with a wealthy historical past and hallowed halls, turns into a personality in its personal proper, contributing to the ambiance of thriller and exclusivity.
-
Setting and Ambiance
Historical universities, libraries overflowing with uncommon texts, and dimly lit classrooms type the backdrop for these narratives. The bodily surroundings fosters a way of each reverence for information and a possible for its misuse. Oxford College, with its centuries-old traditions and architectural grandeur, exemplifies this aesthetic. In fiction, these settings usually serve to isolate characters from the surface world, intensifying their give attention to their research and rising the stakes of their mental and social interactions.
-
Classical Research and Esoteric Information
A give attention to classical literature, philosophy, and historical past is usually central to darkish academia. Characters immerse themselves within the research of historic Greek, Latin, or different specialised fields, in search of that means and even perhaps energy in these historic disciplines. The pursuit of esoteric information can grow to be an obsession, blurring the traces between mental curiosity and a harmful need for forbidden insights. The actual-world resurgence of curiosity in Stoic philosophy demonstrates the enduring attraction of those classical traditions.
-
Themes of Obsession and Ambition
The pursuit of data inside the darkish academia aesthetic can shortly remodel into obsession. Characters are sometimes pushed by ambition, in search of recognition and validation for his or her mental prowess. This ambition can result in unhealthy competitors, rivalry, and a willingness to cross ethical boundaries within the pursuit of their objectives. The historic rivalry between Isaac Newton and Gottfried Wilhelm Leibniz over the event of calculus illustrates the depth that may accompany mental ambition.
-
Ethical Ambiguity and Transgression
The rarefied ambiance of darkish academia fosters an surroundings the place standard morality may be challenged. Characters, immersed of their research and insulated from the surface world, might develop a way of exceptionalism that justifies their transgressions. The pursuit of data, mixed with ambition and the stress to evolve to the group’s norms, can create a slippery slope towards morally ambiguous actions. The fictional exploration of those themes offers a compelling lens by way of which to look at the potential penalties of unchecked ambition and mental elitism.
These interconnected aspects of darkish academia contribute considerably to the attraction of narratives like The Secret Historical past. By combining a charming setting with complicated characters pushed by mental pursuits and shadowed by ethical ambiguity, these tales provide readers a glimpse right into a world each alluring and unsettling. The examination of those themes inside the darkish academia aesthetic encourages reflection on the character of data, the corrupting affect of energy, and the complexities of human ambition.
3. Ethical Ambiguity
Ethical ambiguity varieties a cornerstone of narratives much like The Secret Historical past, driving plot growth and enriching character complexity. These tales usually eschew simplistic portrayals of excellent versus evil, presenting characters whose motivations are multifaceted and whose actions defy straightforward categorization. This ambiguity compels readers to grapple with uncomfortable questions, blurring the traces between proper and unsuitable and difficult standard ethical frameworks. The narrative affect lies within the sustained rigidity created by uncertainty. Readers are saved guessing, continually reevaluating their judgments of characters because the story unfolds and new data involves mild. Take into account the literary instance of Fyodor Dostoevsky’s Crime and Punishment, the place Raskolnikov’s justification for homicide forces readers to confront complicated questions on morality and justice. Actual-world authorized instances involving self-defense pleas equally spotlight the challenges of navigating ethical grey areas.
This exploration of ethical ambiguity usually serves as a car for analyzing the complexities of human nature. Characters in these narratives are hardly ever purely good or purely evil; they’re merchandise of their circumstances, pushed by a mixture of noble intentions and questionable needs. Their flaws and contradictions make them relatable, even when their actions are reprehensible. This relatability permits readers to attach with characters on a deeper degree, fostering empathy and inspiring introspection. The recognition of true crime documentaries, with their give attention to the motivations of criminals, displays a broader societal fascination with understanding the human capability for each good and evil. This understanding enhances the narrative’s psychological depth, offering insights into the motivations that drive people to make tough decisions, typically with devastating penalties.
Recognizing the significance of ethical ambiguity in these narratives is essential to appreciating their thematic richness. It encourages vital pondering, requiring readers to actively interact with the characters’ motivations and the moral dilemmas they face. This energetic engagement fosters a deeper understanding of the narrative’s complexities and its exploration of the human situation. Moreover, it offers a framework for analyzing the broader societal implications of ethical ambiguity, prompting reflection on the challenges of building and upholding moral requirements in a world the place clear-cut solutions are uncommon. The continuing debates surrounding moral dilemmas in synthetic intelligence analysis and growth exemplify the relevance of those explorations in up to date society.
4. Classical Influences
Classical influences, significantly these rooted in Greek and Roman literature, philosophy, and historical past, permeate narratives much like The Secret Historical past. These influences contribute considerably to the thematic depth, mental complexity, and atmospheric richness of such tales. They supply a framework for exploring timeless questions on human nature, morality, magnificence, and the pursuit of data, enriching the narrative and resonating with readers all for these enduring themes. The presence of classical parts usually elevates the narrative past a easy plot-driven story, remodeling it into an exploration of the human situation inside a particular mental and historic context.
-
Historical Greek Philosophy and Tragedy
Ideas from historic Greek philosophy, comparable to Platonic idealism, Stoicism, and Epicureanism, regularly inform characters’ motivations and worldviews. The exploration of tragic flaws, hubris, and the character of destiny, usually drawn from Greek tragedies like these of Sophocles and Euripides, provides depth and complexity to character arcs and plot developments. The affect of those philosophical and literary traditions may be noticed within the characters’ mental discussions and their struggles with ethical dilemmas, echoing the philosophical debates and tragic penalties present in classical works.
-
Latin Language and Literature
The research of Latin, together with Roman literature and historical past, usually options prominently in these narratives, creating a way of mental elitism and reinforcing the characters’ connection to a rarefied educational custom. Using Latin phrases, allusions to Roman authors like Virgil and Ovid, and references to historic figures like Julius Caesar contribute to the narrative’s ambiance and mental texture. The emphasis on Latin underscores the characters’ immersion in a particular cultural and historic context, additional isolating them from the up to date world.
-
Mythology and Symbolism
Classical mythology offers a wealthy supply of symbolism and allegory, enriching the narrative with layers of that means. Allusions to Greek and Roman myths, comparable to the parable of Icarus or the story of Orpheus and Eurydice, can function metaphors for characters’ experiences and foreshadow plot developments. These mythological references add depth and complexity to the narrative, inviting readers to interpret the characters’ actions and motivations by way of the lens of classical symbolism.
-
Artwork and Aesthetics
The affect of classical artwork and aesthetics may be seen within the narrative’s descriptions of settings, characters, and objects. References to classical sculpture, structure, and inventive rules contribute to the general aesthetic tone of the story. The appreciation of magnificence, significantly the idealized magnificence present in classical artwork, usually performs a big position in characters’ motivations and needs, reflecting the emphasis on aesthetics in historic Greek and Roman tradition.
These interwoven classical influences contribute considerably to the distinctive attraction of narratives like The Secret Historical past. By drawing upon these wealthy historic and mental traditions, the narrative creates an immersive expertise for the reader, inviting them to have interaction with timeless questions on human nature, morality, and the pursuit of data. The exploration of those themes inside a classical framework provides depth and complexity to the narrative, elevating it past a easy story of suspense and transgression. Moreover, these influences contribute to the narrative’s distinct ambiance and aesthetic, reinforcing the sense of mental elitism and exclusivity that characterizes these tales.
5. Secrets and techniques and Transgression
Secrets and techniques and transgression are central themes in narratives harking back to The Secret Historical past. The presence of hid data and the violation of ethical or social boundaries generate suspense, drive plot growth, and contribute considerably to the psychological complexity of those tales. Exploration of those themes usually reveals the characters’ motivations, exposes the fragility of interpersonal relationships, and examines the results of unchecked needs and actions.
-
The Attract of the Forbidden
The very nature of secrets and techniques creates a way of attract, drawing characters and readers alike right into a world of hidden information and forbidden needs. This attract can stem from a need for energy, a fascination with the taboo, or just the fun of transgression itself. Actual-world examples, such because the historic fascination with secret societies just like the Freemasons, illustrate the enduring human curiosity within the hid and the unique. Within the context of those narratives, the attract of the forbidden usually motivates characters to cross ethical boundaries, setting in movement a series of occasions with unexpected penalties.
-
The Weight of Concealment
The burden of retaining secrets and techniques can take a big psychological toll on characters. The fixed concern of discovery, coupled with the ethical implications of concealment, can result in paranoia, guilt, and strained relationships. The psychological affect of secrets and techniques is obvious in real-world phenomena like whistleblowing, the place people battle with the moral dilemma of exposing hid data. In these narratives, the burden of secrets and techniques usually contributes to the unraveling of the characters’ fastidiously constructed facades, resulting in inner battle and interpersonal rigidity.
-
The Ripple Impact of Transgression
Transgressive acts, whether or not pushed by ambition, need, or desperation, hardly ever happen in isolation. They create a ripple impact, impacting not solely the person who commits the transgression but in addition the encircling group. The results of transgression can vary from social ostracization to authorized repercussions, as seen in real-world examples of legal conduct and its affect on victims and communities. In these narratives, the exploration of those penalties underscores the interconnectedness of characters’ lives and the far-reaching affect of their decisions.
-
The Nature of Redemption and Forgiveness
Following transgression, the opportunity of redemption and forgiveness turns into a central concern. Characters grapple with the results of their actions, in search of atonement and struggling to reconcile their previous with their current. The exploration of redemption and forgiveness in these narratives usually displays broader societal debates about justice, accountability, and the opportunity of second probabilities. Actual-world examples of restorative justice packages spotlight the complexities of this course of. In these tales, the characters’ journeys towards redemption, or their failure to attain it, present insights into the human capability for each nice wrongdoing and profound transformation.
These interconnected aspects of secrets and techniques and transgression contribute considerably to the thematic depth and psychological complexity of narratives like The Secret Historical past. They provide a compelling exploration of human nature, analyzing the motivations behind each secrecy and transgression, the results of those actions, and the potential for redemption. These explorations present beneficial insights into the human situation, prompting reflection on the character of morality, the fragility of relationships, and the enduring energy of hidden truths.
6. Atmospheric Settings
Atmospheric settings play an important position in narratives much like The Secret Historical past, contributing considerably to the general temper, tone, and thematic resonance. These settings usually operate as greater than mere backdrops; they grow to be integral to the narrative, influencing character growth, shaping plot occasions, and enhancing the emotional affect of the story. The fastidiously constructed ambiance evokes particular feelings and associations within the reader, immersing them on the planet of the story and enhancing their engagement with the characters and their experiences.
-
Isolation and Exclusivity
Remoted settings, comparable to distant boarding faculties, secluded estates, or insular educational communities, contribute to a way of exclusivity and take away characters from the distractions and influences of the surface world. This isolation intensifies the characters’ give attention to their inner lives and interpersonal relationships, heightening the dramatic affect of occasions inside the narrative. The actual-world instance of Mount Athos, a secluded monastic group in Greece, illustrates the affect of bodily isolation on social dynamics and particular person expertise. In narratives like The Secret Historical past, such remoted settings amplify the results of characters’ actions and create a pressure-cooker ambiance ripe for secrets and techniques and transgressions.
-
Temper and Tone
The ambiance of a setting can considerably affect the general temper and tone of the narrative. Darkish, gothic settings would possibly evoke emotions of unease, thriller, and foreboding, whereas brightly lit, bustling city environments would possibly create a way of vitality and pleasure. Take into account the contrasting atmospheric tones of the Scottish Highlands versus the streets of London. In narratives much like The Secret Historical past, the ambiance usually displays the psychological state of the characters, mirroring their inner struggles and foreshadowing future occasions.
-
Sensory Particulars and Symbolism
Vivid sensory particulars, comparable to descriptions of climate, mild, sound, and odor, contribute considerably to the creation of ambiance. These particulars not solely immerse the reader within the sensory expertise of the setting but in addition can operate symbolically, reinforcing themes and foreshadowing plot developments. Using pathetic fallacy, the place the surroundings mirrors the emotional state of the characters, is a typical literary approach used to reinforce atmospheric affect. For example, a sudden storm would possibly symbolize an impending disaster or a personality’s internal turmoil.
-
Historic and Cultural Context
The historic and cultural context of a setting can imbue it with particular associations and meanings. A narrative set in a selected historic interval or cultural milieu will inherit the social norms, values, and anxieties of that point and place. Take into account the completely different cultural connotations of a setting in Victorian England versus one in up to date New York Metropolis. In narratives akin to The Secret Historical past, the historic and cultural context of the setting usually performs an important position in shaping character motivations and influencing the trajectory of the plot.
These interconnected parts of atmospheric settings contribute considerably to the immersive and emotionally resonant expertise of studying narratives like The Secret Historical past. The setting turns into an energetic participant within the narrative, influencing the characters’ decisions, shaping the unfolding occasions, and resonating with the thematic considerations of the story. Understanding the position of ambiance in these narratives enhances appreciation for the craft of storytelling and deepens engagement with the complexities of character and plot.
7. Intense Relationships
Intense relationships are a defining attribute of narratives much like The Secret Historical past. These relationships, usually characterised by complicated dynamics of energy, loyalty, and obsession, drive the narrative ahead and contribute considerably to the psychological depth of the story. Exploring the intricacies of those intense relationships offers essential perception into character motivations, plot growth, and the general thematic considerations of those narratives. They provide a compelling lens by way of which to look at the complexities of human connection and the potential for each profound love and devastating betrayal.
-
Codependency and Enmeshment
Intense relationships usually contain a level of codependency and enmeshment, the place particular person identities grow to be blurred and bounds grow to be tough to outline. Characters might develop an unhealthy reliance on one another for validation and self-worth, resulting in a lack of individuality and a heightened vulnerability to manipulation. The psychological phenomenon of folie deux, the place shared delusional beliefs come up inside a detailed relationship, illustrates the potential for such enmeshment. In narratives like The Secret Historical past, codependent relationships usually contribute to the escalation of secrets and techniques and transgressions, as characters grow to be entangled in an internet of shared duty and mutual dependence.
-
Energy Dynamics and Manipulation
Energy imbalances regularly characterize intense relationships, with one particular person exerting a disproportionate affect over the opposite. This energy dynamic can manifest in numerous varieties, together with emotional manipulation, mental dominance, or monetary management. The historic instance of cults of character, the place charismatic leaders exert undue affect over their followers, demonstrates the potential for exploitation inside such relationships. In these narratives, the manipulation of energy inside intense relationships usually fuels battle and drives the plot towards its climax.
-
Obsession and Idealization
Intense relationships may be fueled by obsession and idealization, the place people challenge their very own needs and fantasies onto the opposite particular person. This will result in unrealistic expectations and a distorted notion of the connection, blinding characters to the failings and pink flags that may be obvious to an outdoor observer. The idea of limerence, characterised by intrusive ideas and fantastical longings for an additional particular person, illustrates the obsessive nature of such idealization. Within the context of those narratives, obsession usually contributes to the depth of feelings and the potential for harmful conduct.
-
Loyalty and Betrayal
Themes of loyalty and betrayal are inextricably linked to intense relationships. The deep bonds solid inside these relationships can result in unwavering loyalty, even within the face of ethical compromise. Nonetheless, the identical depth of connection may make betrayal all of the extra devastating when it happens. The historic instance of the betrayal of Julius Caesar by his shut good friend Brutus highlights the profound affect of such breaches of belief. In narratives like The Secret Historical past, acts of betrayal inside intense relationships usually function pivotal turning factors, shattering the fastidiously constructed phantasm of unity and propelling the narrative in the direction of its tragic conclusion.
These interconnected aspects of intense relationships contribute considerably to the psychological and thematic complexity of narratives much like The Secret Historical past. By exploring the nuances of codependency, energy dynamics, obsession, loyalty, and betrayal, these tales provide a compelling examination of the human capability for each profound connection and devastating disconnection. These explorations present beneficial insights into the dynamics of shut relationships, the results of unchecked feelings, and the enduring energy of human bonds, additional enriching the studying expertise and prompting reflection on the complexities of human interplay.
Incessantly Requested Questions
This part addresses frequent inquiries relating to narratives corresponding to The Secret Historical past, offering additional readability and steering for readers in search of comparable literary experiences.
Query 1: Why are readers so drawn to books like The Secret Historical past?
The attraction stems from a mixture of things, together with the exploration of complicated characters, morally ambiguous themes, and the attract of darkish academia settings. The tightly knit group dynamic, coupled with the burden of secrets and techniques and transgressions, creates a compelling narrative rigidity that resonates with many readers.
Query 2: Are all books much like The Secret Historical past set in educational environments?
Whereas the darkish academia setting is a typical component, not all comparable narratives share this attribute. Some discover comparable themes of intense relationships, secrets and techniques, and transgressions inside different contexts, comparable to remoted communities or particular subcultures.
Query 3: What makes a e book actually corresponding to The Secret Historical past?
True comparability lies within the thematic and atmospheric resonance. Search for narratives exploring the complexities of human relationships, the results of decisions, and the enduring energy of secrets and techniques, usually inside a claustrophobic or intense social dynamic. A give attention to character-driven narratives with a powerful sense of ambiance is usually a key indicator.
Query 4: Past plot similarities, what different parts ought to readers think about?
Take into account the narrative model, prose high quality, and thematic depth. The Secret Historical past is praised for its elegant prose and insightful exploration of human nature. Search narratives that supply the same degree of literary sophistication and thematic resonance, fairly than focusing solely on plot similarities.
Query 5: Are there frequent misconceptions about books like The Secret Historical past?
One false impression is that these narratives are solely targeted on sensationalism or plot twists. Whereas suspense and transgression are sometimes current, the true energy of those tales lies of their exploration of deeper themes associated to morality, identification, and the human situation.
Query 6: How can one uncover extra books with comparable thematic parts?
Exploring on-line e book communities, studying opinions and suggestions, and consulting with educated booksellers can present beneficial steering. Specializing in key phrases comparable to “darkish academia,” “psychological thriller,” and “literary fiction” may assist within the discovery course of.
Readers in search of narratives corresponding to The Secret Historical past are inspired to discover the thematic resonances and atmospheric similarities mentioned above, prioritizing narratives that supply mental stimulation and emotional depth. Specializing in these features will present a richer and extra rewarding studying expertise.
The next part will present particular suggestions for additional studying, categorized by thematic and stylistic similarities.
Ideas for Discovering Related Reads
The following pointers present steering for readers in search of novels resonant with thematic and stylistic parts present in works like Donna Tartt’s The Secret Historical past. Specializing in particular features past surface-level plot similarities will yield a extra rewarding exploration of comparable literature.
Tip 1: Prioritize Ambiance:
Search narratives with a powerful sense of ambiance. Take into account whether or not the setting evokes a particular temper or tone, contributing to the general emotional affect. Search for evocative descriptions and sensory particulars that immerse the reader on the planet of the story.
Tip 2: Discover Character-Pushed Narratives:
Concentrate on tales the place characters’ motivations and internal lives are central to the narrative. Advanced, morally ambiguous characters usually drive the plot and provide alternatives for deeper engagement with the story’s themes. Look at how relationships and particular person decisions form the narrative trajectory.
Tip 3: Take into account Thematic Resonances:
Look past plot similarities and think about shared themes. Discover narratives coping with ambition, obsession, betrayal, the burden of secrets and techniques, and the complexities of human relationships. Thematic depth gives a richer studying expertise than superficial plot parallels.
Tip 4: Examine Authorial Type:
Take note of the creator’s writing model. If drawn to Tartt’s elegant prose and detailed descriptions, search authors with the same command of language. Take into account the pacing, narrative voice, and general stylistic strategy. Authorial model contributes considerably to the studying expertise.
Tip 5: Discover “Darkish Academia” as a Beginning Level:
The “darkish academia” subgenre offers a beneficial place to begin for exploration. Nonetheless, keep away from limiting searches solely to this class. Many narratives share comparable thematic parts with out explicitly becoming this label. Use it as a springboard for broader discovery.
Tip 6: Interact with On-line Guide Communities:
Make the most of on-line assets comparable to e book blogs, boards, and social media teams devoted to literary discussions. Partaking with these communities offers entry to numerous views and suggestions tailor-made to particular pursuits. Actively take part in discussions and search personalised options.
Tip 7: Seek the advice of with Booksellers and Librarians:
Search professional steering from skilled booksellers and librarians. These professionals possess in-depth information of assorted genres and authors, enabling them to offer personalised suggestions based mostly on particular person studying preferences. Describe particular parts that resonated and request tailor-made options.
By following the following pointers, readers can transfer past easy key phrase searches and have interaction with a broader vary of literature that provides comparable complexities and thematic depth. This strategy prioritizes a extra nuanced and rewarding studying expertise, specializing in the core parts that contribute to a very comparable narrative.
The following concluding part will synthesize the important thing factors mentioned and provide remaining ideas on exploring narratives within the vein of The Secret Historical past.
Conclusion
This exploration has delved into the important thing parts that characterize narratives corresponding to The Secret Historical past. Emphasis has been positioned on thematic and atmospheric resonances, highlighting the significance of close-knit teams, darkish academia settings, ethical ambiguity, classical influences, secrets and techniques and transgression, atmospheric settings, and intense relationships. Understanding these core parts permits readers to maneuver past superficial plot similarities and have interaction with a broader vary of literature providing comparable depth and complexity. The main target has remained on offering insights into the nuances of those parts, enabling a extra discerning strategy to discovering comparable reads.
The enduring fascination with narratives like The Secret Historical past speaks to a deeper human need to discover the complexities of human relationships and the results of decisions made inside intense social dynamics. The exploration of those themes inside literature offers beneficial alternatives for introspection and important engagement with the human situation. Readers are inspired to proceed exploring these narratives, in search of out tales that resonate with their particular person sensibilities and provide additional insights into the enduring energy of secrets and techniques, the fragility of relationships, and the seek for that means inside a world usually shrouded in ambiguity.
